How to choose an SEO tool

A plain-English way to choose an SEO tool: decide your main job, count your team, set a budget, then try before you pay.

Updated

We may earn a commission if you buy through links in this guide. It never changes which tools we recommend.

There are hundreds of SEO tools, and most comparison pages just list features. This is the order we would decide in.

1. Decide your main job

Write down the one thing you most need help with:

  • Finding keywords your customers search for.
  • Fixing your website: broken pages, slow pages, missing titles.
  • Tracking rankings week by week.
  • Writing content that ranks.
  • Watching competitors, including their Google Ads.

If it is one job, a specialist tool is often cheaper and better. If it is three or more, look at all-in-one suites.

2. Count who needs a login

Entry plans usually include one person. Extra logins can add $30 to $80 a month each, or force a bigger plan. Our SEO tool cost calculator shows the real yearly cost for your team.

3. Set a budget, then pay yearly

Decide what you will spend a month. Once you are sure of a tool, paying yearly usually saves 17 to 45 percent. Watch for cut-down entry plans (such as Ahrefs Starter) that are cheap because they leave out key features.

4. Try before you pay

Most tools have a free plan or a 7 to 14-day trial. Use it on your own site and ask: did it find real problems, and did I understand what to do?

5. Let a Finder do the sorting

Our SEO tool Finder asks six questions (your main job, team, budget and experience) and ranks every suite for you. Commissions never change the order. Down to two? Use a Decider, such as Ahrefs vs Semrush.

Which SEO tool is right for you?Six quick questions, then your top 3 all-in-one SEO suites, ranked for your needs.

Questions

Questions and answers.

Should I buy an all-in-one suite or a specialist tool?

Buy a suite if you need several jobs done (keywords, audits, rank tracking, competitors). Buy a specialist if one job matters most, such as writing content or auditing a large site; specialists are usually cheaper and better at that one thing.

How long should I test an SEO tool?

Use the free trial or plan on your own website for at least a week: run an audit, look up your main keywords and check whether the advice makes sense to you. If it feels confusing after a week, try another.

Decide for your needs

Get a verdict for your business